Environmental lobby says CAP won’t deliver for the environment

European environmental lobbyists have slammed changes to the delegated acts which it says diminish the reforms ability to impact on the environment positively.

In an open letter to Commissioner Cioloş, the European Environmental Bureau and Birdlife International together said at the beginning of the CAP reform process the Commissioner placed the environment at the heart of the debate, championing policy changes that would ensure that the CAP better protected the natural resources that farming depends upon in return for billions of taxpayers’ money. We, and civil society more broadly, trusted you to continue a trajectory of reform established over 20 years ago but instead vested interests successfully steered the process to a point where virtually all prospects for a greener CAP have been dashed.”

“This betrayal of the original goal is most clear when we consider what has happened to the flagship ‘greening’ measure – Ecological Focus Areas (EFA). EFAs should have resulted in a modest percentage of every farm being managed for the protection of the resource base farming depends on including wildlife.”

“But this honorable objective has been watered down so that at best, EFAs will deliver next to nothing for the natural environment, and at worst will act as a bizarre form of financial support for protein crop production. If labeling law were to be applied in this case, the word ‘ecological’ would be deemed false advertising.”

The organisations outlined that the Delegated Acts of 11 March 2014 already interpreted the Regulation in such a way as to diminish what remained of the green content of the reform. However it says the declaration of the Commission released on 2 April weakens the greening yet further.

It said: “It effectively announces that the rules just adopted are not to be taken seriously because even weaker rules will be adopted in a few months’ time. This makes a mockery of the European Commission’s role.”

“Furthermore, giving in to the demands of a few individual MEPs without any formal request from the European Parliament gives the unfortunate impression that the Commission has been co-opted into someone’s re-election campaign.”

Concluding the organisations said: “In an age of continuing, and worsening, environmental problems, as well as economic pressures across the EU, the fact that public money will continue to prop up harmful farming practices is a scandal of epic proportions.”

Please be considerate of others when commenting. All comments posted are subject to our commenting policy. Comments violating this policy will be removed without notice.