Processor 'sales strategies' questioned amid Irish dairy prices

The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association (ICMSA) has said that "fundamental questions" have been raised by an apparent gap in prices for Irish dairy outputs compared to the rest of the EU.

According to ICMSA Dairy Committee chairperson Noel Murphy, data from the EU Milk Market Observatory "demands answers", and he questioned what he called "the sales strategies being employed by our processors".

According to Murphy, prices being achieved for Irish butter and skim milk powder (SMP) are running behind the EU average, and even further behind other prices for products from other countries.

"These are obviously very significant differences," Murphy said, claiming that this could work out at a difference of €25,000 in revenue for a 500,000L supplier.

"That would be a very serious difference at any time, but in a situation where we have seen dairy incomes [effectively] crash while inputs surge, and all framed against challenging weather conditions... In this context this ceases being any kind of abstract study and becomes an urgent question," he added.

Murphy went on: "Farmers were told non-stop that it was all going to be about stressing the grass-based nature of our products and achieving the sustainability standards that entitled us to premium prices. And the farmers have met and surpassed all those requirements.

"But based on official EU data, it would appear that Irish dairy products are being sold at a discount, with Irish reported SMP price [per tonne] at €3,030 as of November, as opposed to an EU average of €3,540, and German prices of €3,740," he added.

On butter, the ICMSA dairy chair said: "Irish butter is at €3,940 [per tonne], while the EU average is at €4,030 and Czech butter is at €5,450.

He said these prices come after "all the effort made, by the farmers, to achieve the standards that we were told would entitle us to premium prices".

Murphy said that explanations would have to be forthcoming and the effectiveness of sales strategies had to be "on the table".

"There's a gap in the prices that hugely disadvantages Irish milk suppliers," he added.

"We want answers. We need to know what's going on," the ICMSA representative said.

Related Stories

Share this article

More Stories