Farmers ‘irritated’ by ‘reluctance’ to signal green measures mean higher prices

Farmers will be “disappointed and irritated” by a claimed reluctance to signal that environmental measures will mean higher food prices for consumers, according to the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers’ Association (ICMSA).

ICMSA president Pat McCormack criticised sentiments expressed by Minister of State Pippa Hackett on her attendance and impressions of the 13th Global Forum for Food and Agriculture (GFFA).

McCormack said that, while no one doubted the absolute importance of the environmental dimension to the Minister of State’s brief and interests, it was “regrettable” that her release on the GFFA “seemed to omit completely any mention of farmer income or the relentless downward pressure on their margins that is compounding the equally relentless rise of their costs”.

‘Fundamental changes’

McCormack said: “Not for the first time, senior politicians seem unable or unwilling to explain to everyone – not just the farmers – the kind of fundamental changes and challenges arising from the transition to lower emissions.

“We obviously hear the views of Minister of State Hackett – but we seem to be waiting a very long time for any senior politician to say out loud and to the public what everyone had better realise about that transition to low-emissions farming and primary food production.

That process is going to make food more expensive; prices paid by consumers need to rise and we will see the end of the ‘cheap food’ policy that has dictated farming and food in Europe for decades.

“That is just an inevitable consequence of the lowering of volumes that the transition is going to involve and it will mean – it has to mean – that the present system where the corporate retailers estimate what the lowest price that their customers want to pay and then that artificially low price is worked backwards to the farmer who is left with little or nothing will be ending,” McCormack stressed.

“We understand the kind of measures that Minister of State Hackett is talking about – but they will have to be aligned with commercial food production.

‘Dominance of supermarkets’

“Politicians and policymakers must acknowledge this aspect of the environmental issue and not just dwell on what farmers are going to have to do as regards meeting new standards,” the president warned.

Someone is going to have to break the news to the corporate retailers and their customers that the scale and nature of this transition is so enormous and profound that everyone is going to have to accept changes in the way we’ve been looking at the price of food.

“Thanks to the dominance of the supermarkets, people have become used to underpaying for their food.

“That’s going to end as food prices begin to reflect the economic and environmental cost of production – everyone has to realise that and our government and the EU need to recognise and legislate if necessary that farmers get an economically sustainable price for their produce,” the president concluded.