By Natasha Reid
A meat factory worker has been cleared of murder but convicted of the manslaughter of the poker opponent he killed with a boning knife from the factory’s ‘kill floor’.
The accused told Gardaí that he didn’t have any thoughts in his brain at the time, and the defence argued that this showed lack of intent.
The 39-year-old had admitted the killing but denied murder. The Central Criminal Court heard that he used his work knife to stab his housemate after losing hundreds of euro to him in a New Year’s Eve poker game at their home.
Tomasz Paszkiewicz had pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to the manslaughter of fellow Polish man Marek Swider (40) on Dublin Street, Ballyjamesduff, Co. Cavan, on January 1, 2018.
The farm worker died of two stab wounds to his upper body.
Admission and testimony
Paszkiewicz made a number of admissions on the opening day of his trial – including that he had invited the deceased outside following a row that erupted while the two were playing poker at their home.
The accused said he stabbed the deceased with a knife issued to him for his work on the ‘kill floor’ at Liffey Meats in the town.
Zdenek Hebron told the trial that the deceased had won all the money, but that the accused had grabbed it and put it into his pocket. The deceased had said: “Wait, that’s all my money. I won them.”
Hebron testified that the accused then told the deceased to follow him outside. They both left the living room and nobody returned until about five minutes later – when the deceased came back in “holding his tummy”.
He said: “That stupid guy stabbed me. Call ambulance,” recalled the witness.
The court heard that Swider underwent surgery but died on New Year’s Day. A post-mortem examination found that he died of two stab wounds – one to the chest and one to the abdomen.
Discovery of the knife
The boning knife, engraved with Paszkiewicz’s employee number, was discovered at the scene, but the accused was nowhere to be found.
He was crisscrossing the country by bus and eventually walked into a Garda station in Cork City.
The Garda on duty thought the accused was joking when he asked to be arrested for killing a man three days earlier.
We played cards. I drink a lot of vodka. I lost €500. I went crazy. I took this money and left. He followed me.
The accused added: “I don’t know how I had the knife in my hand. We were talking. Then I took the knife and pushed.”
Meanwhile, Cavan Gardaí travelled to Cork to interview Paszkiewicz and he agreed with them that he had become proficient with a knife from years of boning cows’ heads in the meat plant.
“I have to open the cow’s head and cut off the cheeks. That is all I do,” he explained.
The accused told Gardaí that he did not remember going into the kitchen for the knife on the night of the killing, but said that he probably did.
He was asked what was going through his head when he was standing outside face-to-face with the deceased, with a “knife in your hand and you stab him twice”.
“This is not me. Power move my hand over. I don’t decide I go stab him,” he replied.
“I look at his face but I don’t see his face…I don’t have any thoughts in my brain. I not decide move my hand to stab him.”
‘Lack of intent’
Ken Fogarty SC, defending, argued in his closing speech that this showed lack of intent.
“I do say respectfully the prosecution haven’t made out the case of intent sufficient to move this from a charge of manslaughter to murder,” he added.
However, prosecutor Sean Guerin SC said that the story of Swider’s death was a very simple one.
A man, who got drunk playing cards for money, lost his money and became angry with the man who won the money from him. He tried to take it back and was rebuffed.
He continued: “In his anger and covetousness for that money, he brought that man outside, armed himself with the knife and gave Marek Swider no chance. There was no fight. There was barely even an argument. Mr. Swider didn’t lay an arm on him and barely had an opportunity to defend himself.”
Counsel went on to describe it as “an efficient and brutally effective killing”.
Interpretation and intent
Justice Tara Burns, meanwhile, charged the seven men and five women of the jury and sent them out to begin their deliberations yesterday, Wednesday, June 3. They returned and asked her what she had meant when she said that they must acquit of murder if they accepted what the accused had said.
She explained that the interpretation of what the accused said to the Gardaí was completely a matter for the jury. However, she did point out that the issue of intent did arise in interviews – and that this was really the issue in the case.
She said that they should acquit of murder if they accepted that the accused was saying that he didn’t have the intent – and if they accepted that to be true.
Following almost five hours of deliberations, the jury reached a majority verdict of not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter.
Justice Burns remanded the accused in custody for sentencing on July 15 when a victim impact statement is expected to be ready.