A study of river water quality during one of the UK’s wettest ever winters shows a massive increase in agricultural pollution occurred, giving a glimpse of what is to come under future climate change.
Pollutants washing from farmland within the upper catchment of Devon’s River Taw increased dramatically during the winter of 2019/20, with the amount of soil washed off arable/tillage fields – and the associated environmental clean-up costs – showing a twenty-fold increase on average.
Large pulses of such pollution harm both aquatic wildlife and drinking water quality, and the study’s climate modelling predicts the weather pattern responsible will be more common in the future.
The report by Rothamsted Research also shows levels of nitrate, another major aquatic pollutant arising from fertiliser use, increased by four times during the wet winter from recently converted tillage land.
Meanwhile, the sediment lost from grazed grassland areas roughly doubled, with nitrate runoff increasing by about half.
Hydrologist, Prof. Adie Collins, who leads Rothamsted’s research in this area said:
“These changes in autumn and winter rainfall are elevating runoff and the water pollution problems arising from modern farming. Sadly, current on-farm mitigation strategies, including those subsidised by agri-environment schemes, aren’t working very well.”
Weather patterns
February 2020 was the wettest February on record for the UK, with the meteorological winter – December, January, February – ranked as the 5th wettest on record since 1862.
The researchers produced climate predictions for their study site, which suggest this sort of weather pattern will become more common in the future – with the most extreme rain days occurring even more often than they did in February 2020.
Alongside the impact on wildlife, water pollutant emissions affect the provision of valuable ‘ecosystem services’ to humans, according to Prof. Collins, and these impacts were assessed using the concept of ‘environmental damage’ costs.
For sediment loss from fields, environmental damage costs were calculated to be at most £8 /ha (€9.50) during 2016–2019.
During the wet 2019/20 winter, average costs increased three-fold for existing grassland fields – but by more than 20-fold, to about £100/ha (€118), for fields recently converted to arable production.
“Pollution from intensive farming generates environmental damage with resultant costs such as those for drinking water treatment to remove nutrients and sediment,” Prof. Collins added.
“Elevated pollution driven by extreme wet weather increases such problems considerably.”
Pollution monitoring
The data for the research was collected by specialist equipment monitoring the water coming from four fields on a farm, and three other nearby sites within the upper reaches of the River Taw catchment in Devon, as well as readings from a Met Office station based on the farm.
The River Taw rises in the uplands of Dartmoor, while the study sites were in lowland areas, close to Okehampton.
Rothamsted’s North Wyke site is the world’s ‘most instrumented farm’, where all the key inputs and outputs of the site are measured, as well as detailed analyses on soil, air, water and livestock samples.
Millions of measurements of rainfall, flow and water chemistry were collected every 15 minutes for the study throughout a four-year period using state-of-the-art sensors.
The research farm has traditionally been livestock only, but several fields were recently converted to arable to see what would happen as we shift away from meat eating to predominantly plant-based diets on soils classified as not being highly suitable for crop production.
Findings
The data shows how arable farmland can be a much greater contributor to water pollution than lowland grazing livestock, revealing its lack of resistance to wet-weather.
As for the future, climate modelling for this site suggests winter 2019/2020 is a good example of what to expect over the coming decades, said Prof. Collins.
“Compared to the period 1981 to 2010, the 2019/20 winter had nearly 20% more rainfall, with about 209mm falling in February 2020 – which is more than 133% more than the climatic baseline.”
This was the third highest monthly rainfall on record since 1982.
October 2019–March 2020 was most characteristic of predicted future climates with respect to days with more than 1 mm rainfall, according to the professor, and it was this weather pattern that was most associated with sediment – but not nitrate – loss.
“The elevated sediment losses are therefore a good insight into what we might expect in future climates,” he said.