National Planning Framework: Fears rural Ireland will be ‘forgotten about’

Fears were expressed that rural Ireland will be “forgotten about” in the National Planning Framework (NPF) 2040 at a meeting last night in the Hodson Bay Hotel, Co. Roscommon.

Organised by the Coalition Against the National Planning Framework, the meeting was attended by in the region of 300 local representatives, business owners, farmers and members of the general public.

Independent TD for Roscommon-Galway Michael Fitzmaurice, Labour TD for Tipperary Alan Kelly, Fianna Fail TD for West Galway Eamon O Cuiv and Sinn Fein TD for Sligo-Leitrim Martin Kenny all voiced their concerns regarding the plan.

The coalition called for a significant overhaul of the plan in order for it to better serve the country as a whole. The first speaker of the night – Deputy Kelly – explained that this should be a plan for everyone right across the country.

“This is singularly the most important thing for our country. That’s a big statement; but, it’s fact.

This will plan everything. It will plan where population is going; it will plan where our housing is going; it will plan for my children’s futures; it will plan for the next generation – it’s that big.

“Aligned with it is the capital plan; the plan for where we are going to spend billions into the future in relation to vital infrastructure – which will decide where people live, where they go to school, what health services they have, where they work and everything else,” he said.

The Labour TD was clear to say that the NPF is actually a good thing; but, he explained that the plan in its current draft will not work for Ireland as a whole.

“There is one myth I want to kill here and now. This is not about being anti-Dublin or anti-urban; this plan is equally as bad for Dublin as it is for rural areas.

“This plan isn’t ambitious enough, it’s quite generic and it lacks a vision,” he said.

But, there is an opportunity to create a plan that will work for the country, he added.

It is an opportunity to be disruptive; it’s an opportunity to reflect, to embrace change and to plan for that change. That’s why this plan is so disappointing; because, it doesn’t plan for change.

Political representation from 14 counties

One of the other four TDs at the top table, Deputy Fitzmaurice described the turnout at the meeting as a “statement of intent” in relation to rural concerns regarding the NPF.

The rural TD pointed out that there was political representation from 14 different counties at the meeting.

“That tells its own story; that tells us that there is a genuineness of people wanting to come together to make sure that this is done right.

“We’re not opposed to plans. We want to make it better. We want to make sure that – for our generation and the next generation – this will give hope, that this will give a future, that this will give the kids that had to travel alternatives, and maybe having the opportunity to work closer or beside where they were reared or born,” he said.

The independent TD explained that the statistics in the current draft plan indicate that 50% of all the extra people going forward will live in cities, that 23% will live in larger towns and that 16% will stay in rural Ireland.

It is projected in the draft that 50% of all new homes will be built in cities, he added.

The reality of the plan in its present form is that you can draw a line from Dublin to Galway, seemingly the counties north of that don’t seem to exist.

“There is an opportunity now, going forward, for this to be got right,” he said.

‘It’s not a handout we want, it’s a hand up’

Deputy Fitzmaurice rubbished remarks that rural Ireland costs too much, pointing to the €1 billion every month that is generated in exports from agriculture. He believes that there needs to be more done to encourage small and medium-sized enterprises, which offer jobs to people in rural parts of the country.

“In my opinion, and I’ve always said it, I wouldn’t swap my life for any minute; because, living in rural Ireland is one of the greatest freedoms and one of the greatest places you can live.

It’s not a handout we want – no one ever looks for that – it’s a hand up. It’s to try and be given the opportunity to make sure that the next generation can work in rural areas. We need to make sure that socially and economically it is viable,” he said.

The independent TD outlined that the decisions made in relation to this plan will define the success of this Government.

Rural Ireland’s potential

Meanwhile, Fianna TD Eamon O Cuiv stated that rural Ireland has huge potential – but that this plan is designed to inhibit that “enormous potential“.

Referencing author John Healy, Deputy O Cuiv said: “It’s time to shout stop. Maybe in the past we didn’t all shout stop together; but, this time we must – because, the train is leaving the station.

I think it’s time we asked ourselves a fundamental question. Are we running this country to grow an economy, or do we grow the economy to serve the people?

Commenting on infrastructure, he added: “The reality is that if they just gave us the rural broadband and proper mobile service, you’re as connected looking over the Atlantic as you are in the city to the whole world.

“Therefore, the new era we are entering rapidly is going to be a world where you choose to be where you are, where you will be able to work largely from where you are – irrespective of where that is. People are going to have much more flexibility.”

He added that Ireland’s cities are struggling to cope with their populations, housing issues and traffic congestion at the moment – with the draft plan looking to encourage these cities to become even larger.

‘We see our children doing better somewhere else’

Also speaking at the meeting, was Sinn Fein TD Martin Kenny. He rued the fact that young people who grew up in rural Ireland have been forced to emigrate to find work – and will continue to do so if action is not taken.

“I have four children and they’re all teenagers. Most people around me when they rear their children hope they get educated and hope they do well.

All of us look for in life that our children will do better than we do; that’s our ambition. But, where I live – in rural Co. Leitrim – we see them doing better somewhere else, not here.

“That’s the problem for many people in many places, and that needs to change. We need to see a future for our children where we are,” he said.

The mindset of ‘the only chance you have to succeed is to go somewhere else’ needs to change in the Sinn Fein TD’s opinion.

Deputy Kenny also outlined that, regardless of the plan, significant funding is needed to turn the tide in rural Ireland and to encourage creativity and to boost the economy.

The coalition has vowed to take these views and confront the Government in order to draw up a plan that will work for the entire country.