Claire Mc Cormack and Sylvester Phelan
Carcass trim: ‘Farmers are entitled to know the identity of factories’
Farmers whose cattle were subject to excessive carcass trimming by beef factories will be notified by the factories and compensated, Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine Michael Creed has said.
The minister was speaking in the Dail this week responding to a question on the matter from Fianna Fail spokesperson for agriculture Charlie McConalogue, who called for the factories in question to be “named and shamed” and held to account.
Minister Creed outlined that farmers who had been affected by such practices have a right to know which factories were at fault.
I believe any carcass that has been excessively trimmed, that the farmers involved are entitled to know the identity of the factories involved.
“And as you are aware from our engagement last Thursday on this matter, in the context of the ultimate inaccountability and the naming of those factories to farmers, any individual farmer where a carcass has been identified as having been excessively trimmed will be notified by that factory of that matter and duly compensated for it.”
‘Processors to pay’
Last week the minister commented on the issue in detail.
Responding to a question from Charlie McConalogue, Fianna Fail spokesperson on agriculture, Creed said: “I understand that processors will introduce a payment to the farmer supplier to reflect any loss, in each case where [the department] has applied a trim fine on a particular carcass.
I have stressed the need for positive engagement between suppliers and processors and I understand that Meat Industry Ireland has accepted that no individual farmer should be at a loss from a mistake made in a factory in relation to the application of carcass dressing procedures.
Creed said that this measure is part of an “ongoing dialogue” with the meat industry, both within The Beef Forum, and directly with Meat Ireland.
The minister also said that additional inspection services at slaughter plants by department officials were due to be increased.
“Additional monitoring of carcass presentation by my department’s Veterinary Public Health Inspection Staff (VPHIS) in the factories is currently being rolled out,” said Creed.
Creed added that 521 such inspections had already been carried out in 2018, spread across 32 plants, with over 44,000 carcasses examined.
These inspections revealed that 19 carcasses were found to be inconsistent with EU regulations on trimming.
Although this amounts to only 0.05% of all carcasses examined, Creed acknowledged that “one case is one too many”.