Expanding Irish beef production ‘a highly risky strategy’
Expanding beef production is a highly risky strategy in the midst of Brexit uncertainty, dismal farm incomes and the threat of looming trade deals, ICSA President, Patrick Kent, has said.
Kent made the comments at the association’s AGM and annual conference tonight in the Killeshin Hotel, Portlaoise. The Minister for Agriculture, Michael Creed, was also present at the meeting.
‘Agriculture in a Post Brexit World’ was the theme of the conference and Kent outlined the association’s key requirements from the Government on its approach to Brexit.
He stressed the importance of continued tariff free trade between the UK and Ireland due to our unique ties in the agri-food sector and to the mutual benefits accruing.
Kent said that this mutual link must be maintained in an effort to dissuade the UK from looking to South America and New Zealand for beef and sheepmeat imports which Ireland currently supplies and relies heavily on.
“In light of Brexit uncertainty and the threat of further EU trade deals following CETA farmers are simply producing too much beef.
Basic economics tells us what happens when supply is too high for demand.
The President of ICSA also called for a complete review of Food Wise 2025 which he said “could potentially bankrupt farmers if we believe that expansion of production will make us better off”.
On ICSA’s proposal to reduce numbers in the suckler cow herd, he said unlike others who proposed a now dismissed €200m scheme, ICSA proposes to reduce the number of suckler calves born by 20% for one fifth of the cost, at €40m.
He also slammed meat sector proposals to encourage one million extra lambs which would only collapse price. He took exception to the culture of treating farmers like uneducated peasants expected to work 90% harder for no extra gain if Food Wise 2025 targets of increasing exports from €10 billion to €19 billion are to be achieved.
“Simplification should mean paying farmers on time. EU rules which prevent thousands of farmers being paid their first instalment of their BPS every year must be changed,” Kent told the AGM.
He also insisted that the UK exit from the EU must not leave a shortfall but rather be made up of EU Member States making up the difference to retain current budgeting levels.
The ICSA President questioned whether CAP alone can pay for climate change measures and restrictions, adding that contrary soundings from Brussels only added to confusion.
Kent slammed the U-turn on biofuels by the EU which is bad for cereal farmers but also for livestock farmers who need EU grown GM free quality protein which is a by-product of biofuels. It also strikes a blow to any chance of reviving the sugar beet sector in Ireland, he said.
“In any ANC review money must not be lost to Ireland.
Cuts to the payments have impacted the most vulnerable in the farming community in the most marginal lands and that a process of reversing these cuts needs to be implemented.
Kent reminded Minister Creed of the frustration of farmers on the ground at the continued delays in GLAS and AEOS payments, describing it as a wholly unacceptable fiasco which must never be repeated.
On the issue of the possible closure of the Regional Veterinary Labs, Kent said ICSA would oppose any or all closures of the facilities as was demonstrated by ICSA members protesting at the lab in Knockalisheen, Co Clare this week.